Nestled in a truly magical Finger Lakes setting just minutes from Ithaca, Cornell University, and the shores of Cayuga Lake, this one-of-a-kind property offers a rare combination of natural beauty, historic charm, and modern comfort. At its heart is a private 14-foot waterfall and nearly 500 feet of frontage on the cascading Gulf Creek, which winds through a secluded gorge filled with lush vegetation, mature trees, and the calming sounds of rushing water. The ever-changing scenery offers a sensory retreat in every season, from the vibrant colors of fall foliage to the quiet shimmer of winter ice, the fresh greens of spring, and the cool, shaded summers. Perched just above the gorge is a charming and surprisingly spacious home that invites you to take in the stunning surroundings from every angle, whether from a wall of windows overlooking the creek or from one of the many stone patios and walkways that wind through the thoughtfully designed 2.5-acre property. Originally constructed in 1860, this home was expanded in the 1970s and then extensively renovated in the early 2000s, with careful attention paid to preserving its historic character while enhancing livability. The site of an early mill, remnants of the original stone foundation have been artfully incorporated into the landscaping, blending old-world elements with the home’s natural setting. Inside, the bright and open kitchen serves as a true gathering space, featuring a large center island with breakfast bar, maple cabinetry, pantry storage, ample counter space, and open flow to a spacious dining or family room with panoramic views of the creek and surrounding woodlands. The main living room exudes warmth and character, anchored by wide plank floors, exposed wood beams, natural wood finishes, and a rustic stone fireplace that offers a cozy centerpiece for colder months. The main floor layout is ideal for entertaining, offering both intimate nooks and open common areas, along with a convenient half bath for guests. Upstairs, you’ll find a light-filled guest room with vaulted ceilings, a charming office or creative workspace, and a full bath offering peaceful privacy. The walkout lower level includes two well-sized bedrooms, an additional full bath, storage space, and access to a secluded stone patio complete with a hot tub, perfect for relaxing under the stars. The outdoor space is as impressive as the home itself—stone walls, mature landscaping, multiple patios, walking paths down to the creek, open lawn areas for recreation or gardening, and an ever-present connection to the surrounding natural environment. A deep two-car garage offers not only ample parking but also a rear workshop area with under-storage, ideal for tools, gear, or hobbies. In addition, a custom-built 19' x 17' Adirondack-style studio with vaulted tongue-and-groove ceilings, a cedar closet, heating, electricity, and sliding doors to the backyard Whether you're looking for a peaceful full-time residence, a nature-inspired getaway, or a unique investment, this special property delivers a rare combination of privacy, convenience, and timeless Finger Lakes beauty.